Cost-Sharing Reductions: The ACA Benefit Most People Miss

Here's a scenario we see constantly: Someone earning $28,000 per year shops for health insurance on the marketplace. They see Bronze plans with lower premiums and think "I'll save money on the monthly payment." They enroll, feel good about their decision — and then get hit with a $7,000 deductible when they actually need care.

Meanwhile, they could have chosen a Silver plan with a $300 deductible for roughly the same monthly cost.

This isn't a glitch or special circumstance. It's a benefit called Cost-Sharing Reductions (CSRs) that's available to millions of Americans — yet most people have never heard of it. And even those who have heard the term rarely understand how dramatically it can improve their coverage.

If your income is below 250% of the Federal Poverty Level (roughly $37,650 for a single person or $77,800 for a family of four), this guide could save you thousands of dollars in medical bills.

---

What Are Cost-Sharing Reductions?

Cost-Sharing Reductions lower your out-of-pocket costs — the money you pay when you actually use healthcare. We're talking about:

• Deductibles (what you pay before insurance kicks in)
• Copays (flat fees for doctor visits, prescriptions)
• Coinsurance (your percentage of costs after deductible)
• Maximum out-of-pocket (the most you'll pay in a year)

Premium subsidies help you afford the monthly bill. CSRs help you afford actually using your insurance.

The Critical Detail Most People Miss

CSRs are only available on Silver plans.

Not Bronze. Not Gold. Only Silver.

This is why choosing a plan based solely on the lowest premium can be a costly mistake. If you qualify for CSRs but pick a Bronze plan to save $20/month on premiums, you could end up paying $5,000+ more when you need a surgery or end up in the hospital.

---

Who Qualifies for CSRs?

CSRs are based on income, specifically your Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) as a percentage of the Federal Poverty Level.

Income Range	What You Get
100-150% FPL	CSR 94 — Best coverage, lowest costs
150-200% FPL	CSR 87 — Excellent coverage
200-250% FPL	CSR 73 — Meaningful improvement
Above 250% FPL	No CSR — Standard Silver plan

2025 Income Limits for CSR Eligibility

For a Single Person: | CSR Level | Income Range | |-----------|--------------| | CSR 94 | $15,060 - $22,590 | | CSR 87 | $22,591 - $30,120 | | CSR 73 | $30,121 - $37,650 |

For a Family of 4: | CSR Level | Income Range | |-----------|--------------| | CSR 94 | $31,200 - $46,800 | | CSR 87 | $46,801 - $62,400 | | CSR 73 | $62,401 - $78,000 |

---

What CSRs Actually Look Like in Practice

Let's compare what a standard Silver plan looks like versus Silver plans enhanced with each CSR level. These numbers vary by plan and location, but this represents typical improvements:

Standard Silver Plan (No CSR):

• Deductible: $5,000
• Maximum out-of-pocket: $9,200
• Doctor visit copay: $50
• Specialist copay: $75
• Generic drugs: $25
• ER visit: $500 + 40% coinsurance

Silver Plan with CSR 73 (200-250% FPL):

• Deductible: $3,500
• Maximum out-of-pocket: $8,000
• Doctor visit copay: $45
• Specialist copay: $70
• Generic drugs: $20
• ER visit: $450 + 35% coinsurance

Modest improvement — about 30% better

Silver Plan with CSR 87 (150-200% FPL):

• Deductible: $750
• Maximum out-of-pocket: $3,500
• Doctor visit copay: $25
• Specialist copay: $50
• Generic drugs: $10
• ER visit: $200 + 20% coinsurance

Significant improvement — comparable to Gold or better

Silver Plan with CSR 94 (100-150% FPL):

• Deductible: $200
• Maximum out-of-pocket: $1,500
• Doctor visit copay: $5
• Specialist copay: $15
• Generic drugs: $3
• ER visit: $100

Exceptional coverage — better than most employer plans

---

Real-World Examples: Why This Matters

Example 1: Maria, Single, $25,000 Income

Maria is 34 and earns $25,000 as a restaurant manager. That's about 164% of FPL, qualifying her for CSR 87.

Option A: Bronze plan - Monthly premium (after subsidy): $15 - Deductible: $7,500 - If Maria needs an appendectomy costing $30,000: - She pays $7,500 deductible + coinsurance - Total annual medical cost: $9,000+

Option B: Silver plan with CSR 87 - Monthly premium (after subsidy): $35 - Deductible: $750 - If Maria needs the same appendectomy: - She pays $750 deductible + minimal coinsurance - Total annual medical cost: ~$1,500

The $20/month "savings" from Bronze could cost Maria $7,500+ in a medical emergency.

Example 2: The Johnson Family, $55,000 Income

The Johnsons (two parents, two kids) earn $55,000 combined. That's about 172% of FPL, qualifying for CSR 87.

They're relatively healthy, so they initially lean toward a Bronze plan.

Bronze family plan: - Monthly premium: $75 - Family deductible: $16,000 - Son breaks his arm playing soccer: $3,500 bill

Silver plan with CSR 87: - Monthly premium: $125 - Family deductible: $1,500 - Same broken arm: $300 bill

That extra $50/month in premium ($600/year) saves them $3,200 on a single incident — plus peace of mind for anything else that happens.

Example 3: David, Self-Employed, Variable Income

David is a freelance graphic designer. In good years he makes $45,000+, but last year was slow — he made $28,000. That's about 183% FPL, qualifying for CSR 87.

Because David actually uses healthcare (he has a chronic condition requiring monthly specialist visits and medications), the CSR makes a massive difference:

Without CSR (Bronze or standard Silver): - Monthly medication copays: $150 - Specialist visits (6/year): $450 - Annual cost just for ongoing care: ~$2,250

With CSR 87 Silver: - Monthly medication copays: $30 - Specialist visits (6/year): $300 - Annual cost for ongoing care: ~$660

David saves $1,590/year just on routine care — not counting any emergencies or additional needs.

---

The Mistake That Costs People Thousands

Here's the pattern we see over and over:

1. Person goes to HealthCare.gov
2. They see a Bronze plan for $25/month and a Silver plan for $60/month
3. They think "I'm healthy, I'll save money with Bronze"
4. They don't realize the Silver plan comes with CSR enhancements
5. They have a health event — accident, illness, pregnancy
6. They're stuck with a $7,000+ bill on their Bronze plan
7. The Silver plan with CSR would have capped their costs at $1,500

The monthly premium difference often pales in comparison to the deductible difference.

Let's do simple math:

• Extra premium for Silver over Bronze: $35/month × 12 = $420/year
• Deductible difference: $7,000 (Bronze) vs $750 (CSR 87 Silver) = $6,250

If anything significant happens to your health, the Silver plan wins by over $5,800.

And you don't have to get seriously ill. One ER visit for a bad cut. One imaging scan to check out a concerning symptom. One specialist referral. These routine-ish events can easily run $1,000-3,000 — the CSR Silver plan absorbs most of that.

---

How to Get Cost-Sharing Reductions

The good news: You don't have to apply separately for CSRs. When you complete your marketplace application:

1. Enter your expected household income honestly
2. If your income falls below 250% FPL, Silver plans will automatically show enhanced benefits
3. Look for language like "Cost-sharing reduction plan" or notice that the deductibles/copays on Silver plans are dramatically lower than you'd expect
4. Choose a Silver plan

That's it. The CSR is built into the plan itself.

Important Tip: Compare the Silver Plans

Not all Silver plans at your income level will have identical benefits (there's variation by insurer), but they'll all have the CSR enhancement applied. Compare:

• Deductibles
• Maximum out-of-pocket
• Copays for services you actually use (doctor visits, prescriptions)
• Network coverage

The "best" Silver plan depends on your specific healthcare needs.

---

Special Situations

What If My Income Changes Mid-Year?

CSRs are based on your projected annual income. If your income changes significantly:

Income goes down: Report the change. You might qualify for a better CSR tier (or Medicaid if you drop below 138% FPL in expansion states).

Income goes up: Report the change. If you go above 250% FPL, you won't retroactively lose CSRs, but your next year's eligibility will change.

Unlike premium subsidies, you won't have to "pay back" CSR benefits if your income ends up higher than estimated. The plan enhancement you had is yours.

What If I'm Just Over 250% FPL?

If you're just above the CSR cutoff, you have a few options:

Contribute to tax-advantaged accounts: Traditional IRA contributions, HSA contributions (if on a qualifying high-deductible plan previously), or 401(k) contributions reduce your MAGI and could bring you under 250% FPL.

Be strategic about timing: If you have control over income timing (self-employed, investment income, etc.), you might be able to shift income between years.

Look at Gold plans: Without CSR, the gap between Silver and Gold narrows. Gold plans have lower deductibles and may be worth the premium difference.

What About the Coverage Gap States?

In states that haven't expanded Medicaid, adults with income below 100% FPL don't qualify for either Medicaid OR marketplace subsidies. This cruel gap affects about 1.4 million Americans.

If you're in this situation, CSRs aren't available to you either (since the floor for marketplace help is 100% FPL). Some options:

• Community health centers (required to serve everyone regardless of ability to pay)
• State or local programs
• Short-term health plans (not recommended, but exist)
• Charity care programs at hospitals
• Moving to an expansion state (drastic, but people have done it)

---

CSRs and the 2026 Changes

Here's some relatively good news: The 2026 subsidy cliff changes don't directly affect CSRs.

CSRs are tied to income under 250% FPL, and that structure isn't changing. If you're under 250% FPL, you'll still get Cost-Sharing Reductions in 2026.

However, your overall costs could still increase because premium subsidies are shrinking. Even with CSR benefits, you might pay more monthly for the Silver plan.

This makes understanding CSRs even more important in 2026. If you're under 250% FPL, don't let higher Silver premiums scare you into Bronze plans — the CSR benefits are too valuable to give up.

---

Quick Reference: Should I Choose Silver?

Strongly consider Silver with CSR if: - Your income is under 250% FPL - You use healthcare regularly (chronic conditions, ongoing medications) - You have dependents who might need care - You want peace of mind that an emergency won't destroy you financially - You're planning any procedures (including pregnancy)

Bronze might make sense if: - Your income is above 250% FPL (no CSR available anyway) - You're extremely healthy and rarely use healthcare - You have substantial savings to cover a high deductible - You just need catastrophic coverage and are comfortable with financial risk

Even if you're healthy, remember: accidents happen. Appendixes burst. Cars crash. The question isn't "do I expect to get sick?" but "can I afford $7,000+ if something unexpected happens?"

---

The Bottom Line

Cost-Sharing Reductions are one of the most valuable but least understood parts of the ACA. If you qualify:

• CSR 94 (under 150% FPL): You get Platinum-level coverage at Silver prices
• CSR 87 (150-200% FPL): You get Gold-level coverage or better
• CSR 73 (200-250% FPL): You get meaningful improvement over standard plans

The monthly premium difference between Bronze and Silver is almost always worth paying when CSRs are involved. A $30-50/month difference in premium can mean $5,000+ in protection when you need care.

Don't choose your health plan based on the lowest monthly payment. Look at the whole picture — premiums, deductibles, copays, and maximum out-of-pocket. For millions of Americans under 250% FPL, Silver with CSR is the clear winner.

---

Check If You Qualify

Not sure whether your income qualifies for Cost-Sharing Reductions? Take our quick eligibility quiz to find out what benefits are available to you.

[Check My Eligibility →]

---

This guide covers Cost-Sharing Reductions as of 2025. CSR benefits are only available through Silver plans purchased on the official marketplace (HealthCare.gov or your state exchange).